References:
- The very enjoyable Obscure battles blog http://obscurebattles.blogspot.com/2014/11/kolin-1757.html
- The outstandingly good Kronoskaf reference site http://www.kronoskaf.com/syw/index.php?title=1757-06-18_-_Battle_of_Kolin
Blucher rules.
The Blucher rules Blücher – Honour – Sam MustafaPublishing LLC are intended for Napoleonic campaigns and battles but with adjustment
seem to be fine for the Seven Years War (SYW).
As a rule set they are very easy to learn and allow you to fight major
battles such as Kolin with ~90,000 troops.
The rules use a random number of command points, rolled by your
opponent, so a general is never sure how much of his force he can move and is
therefore required to focus on the most important units first. Units (Brigades) have a combat rating (Elan)
which is worn down in combat. In these
rules your Elite brigade will start as more effective than a regular line
brigade but after a combat or two they will have fallen well below the fighting
effectiveness of a, average or even poor quality fresh brigade.
Rule changes
Cavalry in the SYW were not the force they
were in the Napoleonic period. This was
due to a combination different cavalry tactics and better drilled infantry. Infantry in the SYW & WAS did form square,
just not very often and usually when guarding a flank.
I do
not apply the rule that unprepared infantry when in combat against cavalry,
must re-roll its successes for its combat score. I keep
the rule that attacking cavalry Re-Rolls Dice against prepared infantry must be
re-rolled.
Players
I played this game in July with my good
friend John Dance and it was wonderful to have a face to face game after such a
long break. John commanded the Austrians and I the Prussian underdogs.
Battlefield
I set up the battle on my 6’x4’ table and
attempted to put in a few of the key terrain features, mainly the village of Kreczor/Kutlire and the
Swedish works as well as the central Przerovsky hill.
Battle
The Prussian plan was to refuse their right
flank and push the left flank through the Austrian right. The Austrian plan wasn’t to wait for the
Prussians but to advance their centre and left flank and roll up the Prussian
right.
The Blucher rules meant at the Austrians were not sure what types of troops their were facing on the Prussian right.
Unfortunately the Prussians found the ground leading up to Kreczor/Kutlire slow going and the advance was very slow. The Prussian left wing cavalry had a hard fight with their Austrian counterparts. Although the Prussians won, they were a spent force.
The Austrian assault on the Prussian right
wing was much more successful and began to drive the Austrian right wing into
the Prussian centre.
An historically correct result with the Austrians
defeating the might of the Prussian army.
Handsome looking battlefield. Kolin is a battle I have fought many times. I am yet to see a Prussian victory.
ReplyDeleteHi Eddie, my name is George Cowan and I am in the Hong Kong Society of Wargamers (HKSW). I saw your post on the HONOUR Forum. This is fantastic, as I have been thinking the exact same thing for most of this year...converting Blucher to SYW. I am already in the process of doing this with the old Tricolor rules, but Blucher is at a higher level, and a smoother system. Your modification of the cavalry rules makes perfect sense, and I would like to ask more questions, if you don't mind.
ReplyDeleteWhat I have specifically been wrestling with are national characteristics, and am curious if you can shed any light on these? For example, I would give the SYW Prussians the "Firepower" and "Steady" traits for volley and defense; Skirmish trait would only go to units specifically designated as light units, and French "non-foreign" units' elan would be rated at "5 or 6", to everyone else's "6 or 7". Do you have any rules, or insights you can share on this? I would be most grateful if you could, as we play Blucher quite a bit in the HKSW, and are now starting LaSalle 2. Blucher seems a natural fit for the SYW. My emails are zbd3434@gmail.com and zbd34@yahoo.com Thank you very much and I am quite excited to see your write up and looking forward to your reply. Cheers, George Cowan